05 July 2010

Perfection – Friend or Foe?

By Andrea Jordan, Coach, Writer and Corporate Lawyer

Perfection - is it your friend or your greatest enemy? How many of us know someone who is a little (or a lot!) like the character of Bree Hodge from Desperate Housewives; although her home and image is perfectly immaculate this somehow only seems to isolate her from the others.

How much of our lives are frittered away trying to be perfect; worrying about having the perfect job, relationship, home or pair of shoes?

There is nothing wrong with striving for excellence. However, if you cross over into the obsession of perfection you could be damaging your work, health, relationships and yourself.

Inner Critic

The relentless voice of our inner critic is symbolic of perfectionism. Everyone has an inner critic. It's that little voice that pops up when you least want it to and reminds you of your failures and shortcomings, "I should have done a better job than that, my boss isn't going to like it". However, it's when you constantly criticise yourself as a person, that you once again haven't met the impossibly high standards that you set for yourself, that perfectionism becomes a problem.

By becoming aware of that internal voice and meeting it head on you take away its power. Rather than resisting it or ignoring it, focus instead on acknowledging it and recognising its flaws.

Benefits vs. Costs of Perfection

Perfectionism is not necessarily an evil that must be banished completely. An analysis of the costs and benefits can reveal those parts you wish to keep and those you wish to remove from your life.

Although each of us will have a different cost/benefit analysis I thought sharing my analysis could be useful to others:

Benefits of Perfectionism

  • Feel very organised
  • Feel very disciplined
  • Keeps me motivated to grow
  • Confident that I can do a good job
  • Confident that I can achieve whatever I put my mind to
  • Always want to do my personal best
  • Am dependable and reliable

I'm sounding pretty good so far!

Costs of Perfectionism

  • Procrastination
  • Health issues including stress, anxiety, depression
  • Energy to keep up a certain image
  • Lose track of myself
  • Not taking the time to nurture that part of myself that needs to relax and unwind
  • Tendency to be a control freak

Now that is not sounding like someone who is easy to work or live with. The costs of my perfectionist streak are all too clear. Even when writing this article I've had to deal with procrastination as I had doubts that I could write an article that was unique enough to be published.

My Story

Andrea JordanAs a recovering perfectionist I am now constantly on the watch for my inner critic as I know that I can be very hard on myself. I had always thought of my perfectionist streak as an asset because it meant that I always did an excellent job at work. It took me some years to realise that I had become my own worst enemy: I was spending longer and longer at work in an attempt to give everything the Rolls Royce treatment when it wasn't always required.

Spending longer and longer at work, skipping lunch breaks because there was so much to do, not having regular exercise (even though I loved it)… life became a busy rush that revolved around my work. I know that I can't have been a pleasure to work for either; I had impossibly high expectations of those around me and when others make a mistake I was not very forgiving. I liked things to be done my way which meant that I was very controlling and missed opportunities to give my staff more scope to make different suggestions. This is not a great way to live but it's astonishing how many of us live our lives in that way.

We perfectionists are generally not very kind or compassionate towards ourselves. For us, nothing is ever good enough so we get little or no satisfaction from what we have achieved.

Effects of Perfection

Another exercise I found useful when taking a serious look at what perfectionism was costing me was to make a list like the one below. Do any of these items resonate with you? Can you add any more?

Cognitive (thinking)

  • Constant worry
  • Relentless inner critic
  • Inner judge
  • Unrealistic goals
  • Mind churning over negative thoughts

Physical

  • Feeling tired
  • Not sleeping well
  • Constantly tense
  • Headaches
  • Queasy stomach

Social

  • Isolation (my home isn't good enough to invite friends to)
  • Feel like you are boring or uninteresting
  • Social anxiety

Emotional

  • Sad
  • Depressed
  • Feeling down
  • Angry

Beware Of A Shift Of Energy

You can easily become aware of the shift of energy that results when you move from a positive striving for excellence to your detrimental perfection obsession.

 

Imagine you have a project, be it work, a dinner party or a kid's birthday party, that you feel excited about and start to plan. Watch for shifts in your energy from contentment to anxiety. Are you wishing you'd never started the project or wishing that others would give you more time or help? If you become resentful of the time you are spending then you may have shifted to a fear base - and perfectionism loves it there.

If you are unable to catch this behaviour to start with then simply be aware of the after effects as these can highlight any energy shifts that occurred.

 

Reframe Your View of Perfection

Forever chasing the myth of perfection can be very time consuming and exhausting. We all need to recognise that life is messy and difficult and that, sometimes, good is good enough.

 

I know that it can be hard for a perfectionist to honour themselves and to give themselves the time they need. These days I'm much kinder to myself and focus on enjoying the ride as much as the result.

 

Be kind, gentle and loving to yourself. You are your own best friend so stop for a moment, put aside the to-do list and take a moment to breathe.

 

Give yourself a break from chasing that illusion of perfection!

 

Acknowledgement

Andrea Jordan is currently crafting a new lifestyle for herself. She has retrained as a coach and is passionate about personal development and supporting small businesses. Her clients benefit from her 13 years of corporate law experience, as well as her newly acquired internet marketing skills.

Andrea is also available for writing assignments; both technical and creative. You can read more about Andrea, and her recent conservation volunteering trip to D'Urville Island at http://www.learndiscoverbefree.com/ or email andrea@learndiscoverbefree.com

 

Comments (7)

Add your comment
  • Thursday, 08 July 2010, 12:19PM by Philippa Weaver

    “Great article, thanks Andrea. I am a recovering perfectionist also, and I find that giving myself permission to 'pull back' on one role in my life, so that I can pursue my own high standards in another area is a really important strategy. Men don't seem to have been hit so often with this perfectionist gene, so women have to be very vigilant. I always try and encourage the women around me to love what they see as their imperfections. It's really all just perspective isn't it. Thanks for the great piece Andrea, Philippa Weaver”

  • Friday, 09 July 2010, 06:30PM by Jon Dunning

    “Hi Andrea

    A couple of years ago, comments from my boss and then my own coach helped me understand that in certain areas - like writing reports and performance appraisals, for example - I tend towards perfectionism with my desire to add value wherever I can. I could certainly tick 75% of the items you list on a fairly regular basis.

    I now try to stop and say to myself 'you know, sometimes 80% is good enough' as a way to dig myself in the ribs and remind myself not to over-invest. While I'm not sure I agree with Philippa* about the gender bias (I work with more than a few male engineers and PMs with the trait), I do see elements of perfectionism creeping into some of my daughters, especially in the areas of school work, body image and friendship issues - but that's a whole other subject!

    A great article - I hope we will see more soon.

    Jon

    *Hey, Philippa, fancy meeting you here - long time no see!”

  • Monday, 12 July 2010, 03:46PM by Alana Laws

    “Exceleltn article Andrea, I am also a recovering perfectionist, and finding life little less stressful now - so are my Family. Thanks for the reminders. Alana Laws”

  • Friday, 16 July 2010, 03:50PM by Joy Thomson

    “Hi Andrea,

    Thanks for sharing some aspects of your journey.

    I like and resonate strongly with the ‘recovering perfectionist’ label, your thoughts and exercises offer very valuable insights and certainly have made me stop and ‘gasp’ as a couple of points hit home.

    Sometimes a reflection of a behaviour or mindset can be all it takes to recognise it in yourself and really start to shift your energy.

    Look forward to reading more of your posts.

    Joy

    joythomson.wordpress.com

  • Tuesday, 20 July 2010, 08:23AM by Jean

    “What a great piece! All so true, and what so many high-achieving women struggle with. I love Andrea's idea of watching for "shifts of energy". I realised years ago that "the best is the enemy of the good" (ancient Chinese saying I think) and I now try very consciously not to be the best - just good enough, which is a much better place all round. But of course my natural perfectionist sometimes gets the better of me and in future I'm going to try and catch that energy as it shifts.”

  • Tuesday, 27 July 2010, 08:48PM by Andrea Jordan

    “Thanks for all of your wonderful comments. Its great to connect with every one of you and hear about your journeys. ”

  • Wednesday, 25 August 2010, 03:40PM by Jill Porter

    “Great article Andrea.

    My thing with perfectionism came from my Dad who would say "If you can't do it properly, don't do it at all".

    Whilst at times this has been good advice; boy has it stopped me so often. If something was/is new, or I think I can't do it properly/perfectly, I don't do it, or procrastinate for ever!

    I like the shifting energy idea.
    Thanks
    Jill

Add your comment

  • This is not shown on the site, but required for emailing follow up comments to you.